废除富人的谬误案例
经济学人: T wo new books argue for doing away with the rich. Not in the Pol Pot sense of murdering them all, for the writers—a Dutch professor of ethics and the director of a left-wing British think-tank—are impeccably nice. Rather, they favour policies that would make it impossible to have “too much” money. 有两本新书主张废除富人。不是波尔布特意义上的谋杀他们所有人,因为作家——一位荷兰伦理学教授和一家英国左翼智囊团的负责人——都无可挑剔。相反,他们赞成那些不可能拥有 “太多” 资金的政策。 How much is too much? Ingrid Robeyns of Utrecht University in the Netherlands, the author of “Limitarianism”, thinks the state should prevent anyone from accumulating more than $10m (or pounds, or euros; it is a rough figure). In addition to this hard “political limit”, she thinks there should be a much lower “ethical limit”. In countries where the state pays for health care and pensions, no one should amass more than $1m in savings, and society should scorn anyone who does. 多少才算太多?荷兰乌得勒支大学的英格丽德 · 罗宾斯(Ingrid Robeyns)是《限制主义》(Limitarianism)一书的作者,她认为国家应该阻止任何人积累超过 1000 万美元(或英镑或欧元; 这是一个粗略的数字)。除了这